Comma Conventions, Part 3

How are you managing with my comma compilation so far?

Needless to say, there is more.

Some words, such as who, which, and whose, bring comma-plications of their own.

cucumber comma

Essential or nonessential information?

Whether you use a comma or not often depends on whether the clause is essential to the sentence, or nonessential.

For instance…

The footballer, who had trained with the Academy, joined the Wanderers.

This sentence makes sense without the middle phrase. It is nonessential, so bracket it between commas.

Added information requires added commas.

The footballer who had trained with the Academy joined the Wanderers.

In this sentence, that same phrase is essential in order to identify the footballer. Essential information is not added information, so you don’t need added commas.

This principle – that added information needs added commas – was gleaned from an American website that often comes up in my searches. Grammar Girl is easy to understand and often includes handy tips to help you remember.

Sometimes US grammar terms differ from UK terminology but Grammar Girl articles usually point out where UK practice differs from American.

I rarely try to remember jargon anyway – you don’t need to name a principle to understand and apply it – but both sides of the Atlantic seem to agree about commas.


punctuation marks

The principle of added commas for added scraps of information can also apply to other categories of comma. Take, for example, these enclosing commas.

I went to see Jim Broadbent’s latest movie, ‘The Duke,’ with my boyfriend, Bill.

Here, a comma is needed after ‘movie’ (because the movie has already been identified; this and only this is Jim Broadbent’s latest movie). It’s also needed before ‘Bill’, because he and only he is the writer’s boyfriend (unless she’s a lucky girl). Neither phrase is essential to the meaning of the sentence; both are added information and require added commas.

I went to see the movie ‘The Duke’ with my friend Bill.

Here, every word is essential to identify the film and the person.

sad comma

Consider these examples:

My son, Paul, is a bricklayer.

This is correct if you have one son; the name is not essential – it’s added information. But if you have more than one son. . .

My son Paul is a bricklayer.

. . .the name is essential to identifying the person and needs no commas.

Of course, it can never be quite that easy, can it? 

If the identification comes after the name, it should always be surrounded by commas.

Paul, my son, is a bricklayer.


Confused yet?

When your head stops spinning, there are numerous websites and blogs more qualified than I to go into further detail.  Here are another three of the sites I plundered for these articles.

An online search will bring up many more.

Next time…

Words that end in ‘. . .ing’

Should there always be a comma in front of them?

Does anyone have a favourite website they go to for advice?

Please share it with us.

Copyright © 2023 – All rights reserved.

7 thoughts on “Comma Conventions, Part 3

  1. It must have been early in school when I was taught that a pair of commas could lift the phrase between them out as a test. If the sentence still made sense without the phrase I was to leave the commas in place. I think I still subconsciously apply the same test.

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.